ICLR position paper criticized for lacking experiments and making speculative claims — how to respond? [D]
One reviewer criticizes it for lacking an implemented system, empirical validation, results and for making speculative arguments. But its a position/argumentative paper, it doesnt have to have any of those. We provide technical arguments, falsifiable hypotheses, and other contributions, and ICLR ha…
Read the full story at r/MachineLearning ↗
Timeline · 1 report
- 2026-11-07 01:36 · r/MachineLearning
ICLR position paper criticized for lacking experiments and making speculative claims — how to respond? [D]